Ryan Garcia suffered a shock defeat at the hands of Rolando “Rolly” Romero on Friday night in Times Square, losing on points in his first fight since returning from a one-year doping ban.

The B/R combat team was in place to take in all the action, featuring the first live blow-by-blow call from Jim Lampley in more than six years—and compiled a definitive, real-time list of the show's winners and losers. A funny thing happened on the way to Ryan Garcia’s Friday night star turn.

Garcia looked tentative after being dropped in the second round and failed to find any sort of success or rhythm thereafter. The unanimous decision win was a career-best for Romero, who had largely been counted out beforehand. Speaking to Fight Hub TV, 93-year-old Arum passionately said that the matchmaking was to blame.